Passion * Technology * Ruthless Competence

Friday, August 29, 2003

More on Function Interception

I got an email from Steve Maine who used JavaScript's support for function pointers to extend the Page_ClientValidate function. Steve's version calls the built-in version, but then sets the cursor focus to the first invalid control (assuming there are any). Pretty cool.

However, Steve goes on to talk about how quickly function interception can become unmaintainable. Dealing with the ability to override expected functionality is hard enough in object oriented languages. They call it the "fragile base class problem" for a reason. In JavaScript, you have the potential for the "fragile intercepted method problem". Granted, my solution is also "intercepting" a method, albeit in a lo-tech, code injection, search-and-replace kind of way. But maintainability needs to be of paramount importance in system design. I don't want to have to go mucking about in the plumbing primarily because plumbing skills are at a premium (I hear Don is trying to hire them all for his team).

Posted By at 10:23 PM Pacific Daylight Time
Comments are closed.

PDC08

patterns & practices
Summit 2008

Øredev

Change Congress
Recent Bookmarks
Tags .NET Framework (2) ADO.NET (5) Agile (7) AJAX (3) Architecture (284) Guidance (6) Interop (2) Modelling (61) Patterns (7) Process (4) SOA (93) Web Services (5) ASP.NET (24) Battlestar Galactica (3) BI (2) BizTalk (4) Blogging (115) dasBlog (11) Podcasting (4) BPM (1) C# (10) C++ (4) Capitals (5) CardSpace (3) CLR (2) College Football (10) Comedy Central (1) Community (81) Concurrency (6) Consumer Electronics (1) Database (13) Dependency Injection (2) Development (117) C Plus Plus (1) Embedded (5) Lanugages (37) Media (2) P2P (11) Rotor (1) SharePoint (6) SOP (3) DIY (1) DLR (14) Domain Specific Languages (13) Durable Messaging (5) Dynamic Languages (10) Dynamic Silverlight (1) Education (3) Enterprise 2.0 (1) Entertainment (14) ETech (15) F# (51) Functional Programming (17) Game Development (2) Guidance Automation (3) Hardware (8) HawkEye (3) Hockey (29) Home Electronics (1) Home Network (5) Humor (5) IASA (1) Idempotence (3) infrastructure (5) Instrumentation (4) Integration (2) IronPython (27) IronRuby (11) Java (2) Job (3) LINQ (19) Live Mesh (2) Lost (1) Master Data Management (1) Media 2.0 (6) Microsoft (29) MIX06 (2) Mobile Phone (1) Monads (5) Morning Coffee (172) Object Oriented (4) Office (5) Open Source (5) Open Space (2) Operations (3) Other (135) Art (1) Books (1) Family (31) Games (18) General Geekery (26) Home Theater (1) Movies (23) Music (20) Politics (3) Society (1) Sports (37) Working at MSFT (15) Parsing Expression Grammar (16) patterns & practices (2) PDC08 (2) Politics (42) PowerPoint (2) PowerShell (33) Presentation (5) Projects (1) HawkWiki (1) Python (4) Quote of the Day (4) Refactoring (1) Research (2) REST (18) Reuse (5) Robotics (2) Rome (5) Ruby (23) Ruby on Rails (1) Sci-Fi (2) Scripting (4) Security (3) Service Broker (14) SharePoint (2) Silverlight (18) Social Software (1) Software + Services (2) Software Design (1) Software Factories (11) Software Industry (1) Spark (1) SQL Server (2) Stephen Colbert (1) TechEd (7) TechEd06 (1) TechRec League (1) Television (6) Travel (6) Unified Client (1) Unit Testing (4) UX (1) Virtual PC (2) Visual Basic (1) Visual Studio (20) Volta (2) Washington Capitals (34) WCF (31) Web 2.0 (65) Web Services (5) WF (21) Windows Live (23) Xbox (1) Xbox 360 (53) XML (7) XNA (14)
Disclaimer: The information in this weblog is provided "AS IS" with no warranties, and confers no rights. This weblog does not represent the thoughts, intentions, plans or strategies of my employer. It is solely my opinion. Inappropriate comments will be deleted at the authors discretion.